Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Amy Karol

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

State Farm® Insurance Agent

Amy Karol

Amy Marie Karol Ins Agency Inc

205 Sunrise Highway
Lynbrook, NY 11563

1/4 mile East of Dunkin' Donuts

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Amy Karol

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call us 24 hours a day!


205 Sunrise Highway
Lynbrook, NY 11563


English, Spanish, Russian

** Online auto quotes are not available at this time. We would love to help you. Please contact our office during regular business hours.

🎁Get Rewarded for Your Insurance Quote! 🎁

Are you looking for a smart and rewarding way to explore your insurance options? Look no further! We are thrilled to introduce our limited-time Gift Card Exchange Promotion! Get a FREE $15 gift card just for getting an insurance quote from us! This is for prospective customers only.

Welcome to Amy Karol State Farm Agency! I am Amy Karol, and for the past 17 years, it has been my honor to serve the Lynbrook community. But our service extends far beyond Lynbrook - we are also here to assist customers in East Rockaway, Oceanside, Hewlett Bay Park, Woodmere, Baldwin, Cedarhurst, and throughout Nassau and Suffolk counties, as well as the entire state of New York!

My team and I are dedicated to helping you with all your insurance and financial needs. We understand that navigating the world of insurance can be overwhelming, which is why we offer free quotes to ensure you have all the information you need to make informed decisions. Whether you need auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, health insurance, personal articles insurance, or personal liability umbrella insurance, we've got you covered.

Purchasing your first home is key life event, we want to make sure you understand all your home insurance coverage options. Give us a call today to make sure there are not any gaps in your homeowners insurance coverage.

We strive to provide all our customers with an amazing customer service experience, here is what one of our customers thinks of us:

“Excellent customer service & very helpful breaking down information. Made the whole process stress-free and easy.”

If you want to see what others are saying, please click the review link located above.

When I'm not serving my customers, I enjoy spending time with my family and friends. With three active kids, my husband and I are kept on our toes, supporting them in their community service and sports activities. We also love spending time out on our boat, exploring the beautiful waters of the south shore and enjoying the sights around Long Island, NY. If you share a love for the great outdoors, come by my office, and let's discuss how we can protect you from unexpected events. We offer insurance for motorcycles, boats, recreational vehicles/campers, ATVs, antique cars, jet-skis, and snowmobiles. No matter what activity you enjoy, we have you covered!

The Drive Safe and Save Discount is a way to help you save on your Auto Insurance. Text ENROLL to 42407 to sign up or simply call us anytime! We are here to help you save!

As a small business owner, I understand the importance of protecting your business. Being part of the small business community allows me to share my knowledge and provide other business owners with serenity in the face of unexpected events. We offer auto and fire commercial insurance, workers' compensation insurance, business liability insurance, and commercial liability umbrella insurance.

My team and I are always here for you. You can call us 24/7 for a complimentary insurance quote, or if you prefer, stop by our office, and say hello. We are more than happy to spend time with you discussing your insurance needs. And now, we also offer virtual appointments, so you can have a convenient appointment from the comfort of your own home.

At Amy Karol State Farm Agency, providing outstanding customer service is our top priority. We are committed to going above and beyond to deliver remarkable service to our customers. Whatever your insurance needs may be, we are here to help. Contact us today and experience the State Farm difference!

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health

Other Products

Banking, Mutual Funds, Annuities

How to create a retirement income plan

Creating a retirement plan that works requires a balance of budgeting and savvy retirement income strategies.

Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself

To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.

How to help with separation anxiety in dogs

Learn about separation anxiety in dogs and how you can help your furry family member.

View More Articles

At the Amy Marie Karol State Farm Agency, we stand as a beacon of unwavering commitment to our community and customers, guided by the core principles of quality service, meaningful relationships, and unassailable integrity. Our mission is to provide more than just insurance products; we strive to build a haven of respect and dependability where individuals, families, and businesses can find security.

Amy Karol State Farm Agent and her team are dedicated professionals committed to delivering exceptional customer service. We understand the importance of providing a personalized insurance plan that not only meets your specific needs, but also fits your budget. Our goal is to help you save money while safeguarding what matters most to you - your family, possessions, and financial security. With our range of offerings, including safe driving rewards, bundling options, and various discounts, we can personalize the products that are perfect for you. Whether you prefer to visit our office or give us a call, we are ready to assist you.

Renee Cicalese State Farm Agent Team Member

Renee Cicalese

Office Manager

I have been part of the State Farm family for 9 years, over 3 years with the Amy Karol Agency. I am the Office Manager/Customer Service Manager and we pride ourselves on providing outstanding service. I am licensed in Personal and Commercial lines, Life, Accident and Health. I am a NYS licensed Notary. I am here to provide assistance or guidance on any product that State Farm offers!

I am a mom to 2 amazing sons. I love spending time with my family and the beach is my happy place. 😊

We are an experienced team and we are always here to help!! Service done right!

RJ Gatchalian State Farm Agent Team Member

RJ Gatchalian

Account Manager

I am a Long Island native. I have experience in directing my customers in the right direction. I am licensed to guide you for all your needs in auto, home, commercial, life and health insurance. Helping others is my passion. When I’m not with my son, I love what New York has to offer from the sports teams (Jets, Knicks, Rangers and Yankees) to the beaches, skyline, hiking and food especially their donuts. Well not just New York donuts, all donuts big and small. And remember there is always something to be grateful for.

Luis Martinez State Farm Agent Team Member

Luis Martinez

Account Manager

Hola! I worked in the computer industry until becoming a stay-at-home dad. Thereafter, I chose the insurance industry and learned to take care of new families through the many products State Farm offers including Life, Home, Auto and Commercial insurance. Getting to know your family is important to me and ensuring you needs are met. I can do this in either fluent Spanish or English.

Long Island has been my home since graduating from Dowling College. I live with my wife and two sons in Islip Terrace. I enjoy travel and making specialty drinks for family and friends!

Please reach out to discuss any of your family insurance needs!


Jennifer Scatigno

Office Representative

I joined the Amy Karol Agency in 2014 and have a personal lines license. My position here is to assist customers with all types of servicing needs. I enjoy working along with the wonderful team that our office has, and always try my to help our customers however I can. I grew up in Queens and now live in Franklin Square with my family and my Siberian cat!

Sebastian Turcios State Farm Agent Team Member

Sebastian Turcios

Account Manager

Hi! I have been apart of State Farm for 3 years now. throughout those 3 year I have learned how important it is to protect your family, yourself, and your assets. I am Licensed in Auto, Home, Business, Life, and Health Insurance to help you protect what’s most important! I was born and raised in New York and fluently speak English and Spanish. I am a car enthusiast, big brother, and father to Lexi my German Rottweiler! I would be happy to discuss all the different products State Farm has to offer that will help you feel safe, protected, and secure. If I am unavailable be assured, that our team at the Amy Karol State Farm Agency are more than experienced and happy to help you with your needs.

Jacob Kukafka State Farm Agent Team Member

Jacob Kukafka

Account Representative

Jacob Kukafka is a dedicated professional working at the Amy Karol State Farm Agency. With his Property & Casualty License and Life Accident and Health License, Jacob brings a wealth of knowledge and knowhow to his role.

Outside of work, Jacob enjoys exploring his passion for music and the great outdoors. He is an avid concert-goer, often attending shows with friends. Additionally, he finds solace in various outdoor activities throughout the year. Whether it's hitting the slopes for snowboarding during the winter or embarking on kayaking and hiking adventures with his faithful dog in the warmer months, Jacob truly appreciates the beauty of nature.

Jacob's journey has taken him through different paths, as he initially pursued a career in audio engineering after attending college. During this time, he had the privilege of working alongside well-established artists in the industry. However, after careful consideration, Jacob decided to shift gears and pursue his current profession, where he can utilize his skills and make a positive impact.

With his diverse background and passion for both music and the outdoors, Jacob brings a unique perspective and well-rounded approach to his work at the Amy Karol State Farm Agency.

Our Agency

Learn more about our agency and the career opportunities with us.
Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.